Abortion Rights And Wrongs

Narrow Definition of Person

Continue On
CONTINUE ON
Related Ideas
Review Related Ideas and then Return Here
Quotation
Source

Philosopher Mary Ann Warren has argued for very high standards of personhood and hence her concept of a person is a narrow one. She argues that the traits most "central" to being a person include consciousness, reasoning, self-motivated activity, the capacity to communicate, and having a self-concept. Without arguing that any one of these traits is necessary for personhood, she points out that the embryo/fetus has none of them. It follows that neither the embryo nor the fetus is a person in any ordinary sense.

This type of a definition separates species membership (a biological fact) from personhood (a moral status). It also discounts potential in favor of the actual manifestation of the traits in question.


Reference: Warren's article "On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion" is included in both the Baird and Feinberg anthologies.

Ariadne Home Abortion Bibliography Abortion Home