Ariadne's Thread on
                        Property
Replies
Next speaker on the
                          main path
Dee

(main path)





On Property

(Click here to continue on the main path)

 Vera Speaking

Current speaker I am not against some sort of self-ownership. But I don't see how you can make the transition from self-ownership to the ownership of natural resources like land or water or minerals. That's just hocus-pocus. Hand waving.

Even Nozick admitted that it wasn't at all clear how the transition would work. Why don't people who mix their labor with a natural resource simply lose their labor? That's what happens when they mix their labor with the ocean, isn't it?

You have to do better than this, Dee.





Ariadne's Home Contact Ariadne at: Property Home
Property Bibliography Property Contents