|
|
| Relativism:
For and Against
|
|
(Click here to return to the main path) |
Vera Speaking
|
Here's
another problem that cultural relativism has to deal with:Cultural relativism assumes that we can say
what culture an
individual belongs to. That may seem obvious when we think in the
abstract or look at small cultures from a distance. But is it?
Maybe it's not so easy matter to define the boundaries of a culture.
Think about these questions:
- What if a person belongs to a subculture within a larger
culture? Suppose she is an Italian American in 1910 when
there were millions a recent Italian immigrants in the US. Which
culture does the person belong to? Which cultural standards
apply to their behavior? Which standards are binding on that
person?
- What if a person belongs to many different groups within a
larger culture? For example, a person may belong to a religious
group, an ethnic group, an occupational group, a racial group,
an so on. If all these groups have some ethical standards, which set of
standards is binding? If standards conflict, which one is the
controlling standard?
I think some anthropologists have had an idealized model of a culture in
which these issues did not arise. But in the real world they do, and I
am not so sure that cultural relativism has answers.
|
|