No Way to Decide?
	CONTINUE ON	Review Related Ideas and then Return Here

What if we carefully consider our ordinary moral concepts and intuitions and come to the conclusion that they do not logically entail an answer to such questions as "Should we confer the rights of personhood on the embryo/fetus?" or "Is abortion intrinsically wrong?" or "Does the mother usually have the right to withdraw the support of her body from her child?"

If this is the case, would it be morally permissible (perhaps morally best) to decide the issues on the basis of extrinsic considerations? Extrinsic considerations include such matters as whether the child is wanted, whether he or she will be healthy, whether the family's standard of living will go up or down if there is another child, whether the mother's career will be harmed, and so forth. Keep in mind that some extrinsic considerations are moral considerations and some are merely prudential. Does that matter?

Ariadne Home	Abortion Bibliography	Abortion Home